Tucked away in the highly desirable College View Estates neighborhood near San Diego State University, 5386 Penny Place presents a rare opportunity to own a versatile move-in-ready property with incredible long-term potential. The flexible floor plan features 4 bedrooms and 3 full bathrooms, including two en-suite bedrooms that provide ideal separation and functionality for a variety of living arrangements. The additional bedrooms are well-sized and share a third full bath, creating a layout that adapts effortlessly to changing needs over time. Inside, the kitchen was recently refreshed with updated tile flooring and offers a functional footprint ready for everyday living or future customization. A newer roof and updated electrical and HVAC systems provide added peace of mind, while the homes strong rental history over the past 13 years highlights its consistent appeal and investment potential. Additional improvements include a new water heater and bathroom faucets, as well as newer kitchen appliances, interior and exterior paint, a recently constructed wood front deck and stairs, a concrete walkway, an updated gutter system, and a newer garage door with automatic opener. A detailed list of improvements completed over the past three years is available upon request. Step outside to enjoy the expansive backyard, where canyon views, privacy, and low-maintenance landscaping create a peaceful outdoor setting with endless possibilities. Whether envisioning an entertainers retreat, garden oasis, or future value-add improvements, the oversized lot offers room to bring your ideas to
- Swimming Pool:
- N/K
- Heating System:
- Forced Air Unit
- Cooling System:
- Central Forced Air
- Fireplace:
- N/K
- Parking:
- Garage
- Flooring:
- Tile, Wood, Carpet
- Interior Features:
- Granite Counters
- Sewer:
- Public Sewer
- Appliances:
- Dishwasher, Microwave, Refrigerator, Gas Cooking
- Country:
- US
- State:
- CA
- County:
- SD
- City:
- San Diego
- Zipcode:
- 92115
- Street:
- Penny Place
- Street Number:
- 5386
- Longitude:
- W118° 54' 59.2''
- Latitude:
- N32° 46' 29.4''
- Directions:
- Head east on Montezuma Rd. Turn left of Yerba Santa Drive which turns into Yerba Anita Drive. Then turn right on Yerba Anita "Way". Right on College Gardens Ct. Left of Hewlett. Left of Manhasset. Right on Penny Place and property is on your left.
- Zoning:
- R-1:SINGLE
- Elementary School District:
- San Diego Unified School Distric
- High School District:
- San Diego Unified School Distric
- Middle Or Junior School District:
- San Diego Unified School Distric
- Office Name:
- Swell Property
- Agent Name:
- Nikole Ferrari
- Building Size:
- 1719
- Entry Level:
- 1
- Garage:
- 2
- Levels:
- 1 Story
- On Market Date:
- 2026-06-10
- Stories:
- 1
- Stories Total:
- 1
- Virtual Tour:
- https://www.propertypanorama.com/instaview/crmls/NDP2605570
- Co List Office Mls Id:
- CR-DC6031
- Co List Office Name:
- NON LISTED OFFICE
- List Agent Mls Id:
- CRP-107060
- List Office Mls Id:
- CRP-12450
- Listing Term:
- Submit
- Mls Status:
- ACTIVE
- Modification Timestamp:
- 2026-06-11T01:25:34Z
- Originating System Name:
- CRP
- Special Listing Conditions:
- Standard
Residential For Sale 4 Bedrooms 5386 Penny Place, San Diego, CA 92115 - Scottway - San Diego Real Estate
5386 Penny Place, San Diego, CA 92115
- Property Type :
- Residential
- Listing Type :
- For Sale
- Listing ID :
- NDP2605570
- Price :
- $1,249,900
- View :
- Valley/Canyon
- Bedrooms :
- 4
- Bathrooms :
- 3
- Square Footage :
- 1,719
- Year Built :
- 1955
- Status :
- Active
- Full Bathrooms :
- 3
- Property Sub Type :
- Detached